Make these ads go away.
+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: American GI's get annoyed.

  1. #1
    gmc
    Currently Offline
    Senior Member
    This user has no status.
     
    I am:
    ----
     

    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Scotland
    Posts
    13,013
    Local Date
    01-17-2018
    Local Time
    07:16 AM
    Points
    26,966
    Gifts Cocktail Car Beer

    American GI's get annoyed.

    Nazi SS guards being tortured in Dachau witnessed by American Army doctor | Daily Mail Online

    No surprise there seems like the revisionists are at it a little bit I doubt anyone at the time would have condemned the troops any more than they would condemn the bomber pilots - the bombing campaign wasn't controversial at the time it was only later politicians of the time tried to pretend they opposed it on moral grounds. These things happen we shouldn't be surprised is it right to be so condemnatory now?

    I knew a british veteran ( well OK he was scots) in the tank corps one of those at bergen belsen he told a story how they had the german guards throwing the bodies in the mass graves and useing a bulldozer to fill it in when some of the germans got caught up in the moving earth (presumably the driver couldn't see them) and buried alive. I always remember the way he put it that he saw british troops do something he never thought he's see - they turned their backs and said nohing. When I asked what he did about it himself and bear in mind unlike the american this as a guy who had fought in the desert campaigns drove a flail tank on d-day and later one of the churchill crocodile tanks he said at that point he didn't care any more he'd lost a lot of mates and quite frankly it's not something that bothered him thirty five years later it was a memory he could look at dispassionately. My dad had fought in the desert as well but he never talked about it - at least not to a child. In my experience soldiers who have been in actual combat tend not to talk about it and in my parents generation there were an awful lot that didn't tlk about it but there must have been a lot of times soldiers didn't take prisoners or even offer the option.

    Incidents like Abu grahib and my lai were cold blooded and rightly condemned I'm not so sure these kind of incidents fall in to the same category.

  2. #2
    Senior Member
    is Copyright J.R.R. Tolkien.
     
    I am:
    Cool
     
    Smaug's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Location
    Midlands
    Posts
    1,599
    Local Date
    01-17-2018
    Local Time
    07:16 AM
    Points
    6,416
    Gifts Boxing Gloves Certificate Car

    Re: American GI's get annoyed.

    Register to remove this ad.
    Quote Originally Posted by gmc View Post
    Nazi SS guards being tortured in Dachau witnessed by American Army doctor | Daily Mail Online

    No surprise there seems like the revisionists are at it a little bit I doubt anyone at the time would have condemned the troops any more than they would condemn the bomber pilots - the bombing campaign wasn't controversial at the time it was only later politicians of the time tried to pretend they opposed it on moral grounds. These things happen we shouldn't be surprised is it right to be so condemnatory now?

    I knew a british veteran ( well OK he was scots) in the tank corps one of those at bergen belsen he told a story how they had the german guards throwing the bodies in the mass graves and useing a bulldozer to fill it in when some of the germans got caught up in the moving earth (presumably the driver couldn't see them) and buried alive. I always remember the way he put it that he saw british troops do something he never thought he's see - they turned their backs and said nohing. When I asked what he did about it himself and bear in mind unlike the american this as a guy who had fought in the desert campaigns drove a flail tank on d-day and later one of the churchill crocodile tanks he said at that point he didn't care any more he'd lost a lot of mates and quite frankly it's not something that bothered him thirty five years later it was a memory he could look at dispassionately. My dad had fought in the desert as well but he never talked about it - at least not to a child. In my experience soldiers who have been in actual combat tend not to talk about it and in my parents generation there were an awful lot that didn't tlk about it but there must have been a lot of times soldiers didn't take prisoners or even offer the option.

    Incidents like Abu grahib and my lai were cold blooded and rightly condemned I'm not so sure these kind of incidents fall in to the same category.
    I'm not surprised he didn't talk much about it. My Grandpa was the same. The article reminds me a little of the holocaust deniers, insomuch as it's also "revisionist". I think it's becoming a fashion...

    I'm quite prepared to accept that atrocities WERE committed by "our" troops at times though. Hardly surprising when you consider the unimaginable horrors they had to face, stuff we've never had to, because of their bravery, determination and sacrifice. Let's hope it never happens again....though they say that history often repeats itself.
    " To finish first, first you have to finish!" Rick Mears. 4x Winner Indy 500. 3x Indycar National Champion.

+ Reply to Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.5.2