ForumGarden

tmbsgrl wrote: I think that girl that had singing lessons from her mom is going to go far in the competition. I am not sure if she'll win but I like her.


she was fantastic!

There were some good ones both in Greensboro and San Francisco. Wonder what Las Vegas will give us.

There were two girls, the one already mentioned and a white girl that the judges heaped praises on so much she cried. Simon called her 'current'

Anybody see Idol from Vegas last night?? Those people, for the most part, were awful! I don't mean to be so critical, but there wasn't a lot of talent there.

It was pretty funny that they didn't let a couple of guys even start to sing before sending them packing. :wah:

Accountable wrote: It was pretty funny that they didn't let a couple of guys even start to sing before sending them packing. :wah:


they said in the end they only choose 11 to go to hollywood whoooooweee not very many, but yes I agree last nite was crap utter crap. I feel Simons pain ahahahaha

tmbsgrl wrote: So what have you all thought about American Idol the past 2 weeks?? Who were your favorites & who did you not like?? I am starting to not like the twins anymore (the ones that were in trouble) They think they know everything!!! & how about that guy that jumped in front of Simon, Paula & Randy on Wednesday! That was so funny! I like to watch Paulas':-3 Face.


I liked the lovely pair of girl twins who looked very glam with gorgeous skin and hair, and only one could sing as the other had to have emergancy throat surgery ok so I guess only one was advancing but I liked her voice a lot.

Oh DID YOU SEE the dude who sang .... Cher OMG that gave me nightmares that was hideous!!

tmbsgrl wrote: He made me laugh so hard... I was cracking up when him & Simon got into it!! Oh and how about that guy that thought he was the next Clay Aiken!:-2


oh yeah I forgot about him ahahaha plain freakish ahahahaha but funny his face was a hoot how it contorted when he sang Jr Minks and I could not stop the tears and laughter.

Well watched the first of Hell week. Was sooo glad to see the little cowboy make it through. He's got my vote.

Ya think they're purposely not showing the people they think are the best of the best?

I was very disappointed to see the other set of boy twins get booted! They were good!! But what happened to the senator's & news-lady's daughter?? They didn't show her last week... at least, not that I saw.

Anybody catch "Broke Tune Mountain" last night? :wah:



And "my spirit is broken. :-1 I quit!" :-2 "Wait! I don't quit"

I'm watching bits of it on ITV 3. I'm not sure how far behind you our programmes are though. Think I remember the young cowboy lad.

tmbsgrl wrote: Yes i caught it all. I was disappointed that they let the little cowboy go home. But At least he got to see the ocean & go to Hollywood! I am sure he is just happy he made it that far!!



As far as the 2 twins.. I want them to go home.. I am so freakin sick of them!! Why on earth would Simon let them stay?
Producers! You forget that this is TV as well. They'll keep them another week then cut them loose.

I agree about the twins. Once they threw their hissy fits & quit, they should've stayed that way... although it seemed only the one quit for both. But what are they gonna do when they finally DO get canned??

I felt bad for all the cowboy group. But they did do a terrible job. Also that girl who kept switching groups... she was a jerk.

tmbsgrl wrote: Yeah she was! I was getting mad at her! She was really annoying me but not as bad as the twins.
The first group should never have let her back in.

I was sad to see the little cowboy leave. The twins I'm sick of, wish they didn't let them back in.

The good part of the show has finally started. Let's see who shines and who tanks. :guitarist

I loooooove the big girl that went tonight! We need an idol who looks like the REAL America!

What was her name? Its back on...wait...its, this Donohoe girl is really pretty!

I don't like the girl who posed the whole time she was on stage with Ryan. Ugh!

There was many whom I liked Paris, Kelly, Katharine, and Lisa. All their performances were great.

If you will note my prediction on page one, it looks like I may not have been too early after all.



That last girl melted me with that last note "youuuuuuuuuu" but I figure that's just because I'm alone.



Both the younger girls were awesome!

Aww but according to this website one of the guys is picked to be the winner. Ace Young.

http://www.realitytvworld.com/americanidol5/

Sheryl wrote: Aww but according to this website one of the guys is picked to be the winner. Ace Young.



http://www.realitytvworld.com/americanidol5/
Nah. Too pretty. He'll never make it.

Accountable wrote: Nah. Too pretty. He'll never make it.





I don't think so. I'm thinking there's gonna be a lot of girls swooning over him and voting for him.

Sheryl wrote: I don't think so. I'm thinking there's gonna be a lot of girls swooning over him and voting for him.
pffft. He's another ... what was that Greek kid's name?n Constantine!

Constanine

Sheryl wrote: Constanine
Right. His pouty lips didn't get him far enough, did they?

But he wasn't that great of a singer. I liked Bo.

Sheryl wrote: But he wasn't that great of a singer. I liked Bo.
Bo's cool, alright. I think he may be too purist to make it big.



From what I've seen this new guy has pipes. We'll see tomorrow.

tmbsgrl wrote: I liked Bo too! I do like Ace. But I voted for 4 girls.. Kellie (02) Lisa(10) Katherine(12) and Ayla (04) I voted continously until I couldn't vote anymore! I loved Katherine or whatever her name is. (the last one) She was great. I like Lisa last night she was GREAT! She really shocked me. Hubby liked Ayla. Tonight I'll be watching for Chris and Ace. I like them both. :DLisa was the 16-year-old?

Becky's as good as gone. She won't last.



What about the little girl? The 17 year old with the famous grandma?

Katherine's personality reminds me of Kelly Clarkson. We'll definitely see her for quite awhile.