ForumGarden

Rev. Phelps and others have been protesting at soldier's funerals and even protested at the miner's funerals in W. VA. Interested other's opinions. Do they have a legal right to protest at such events.

http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/news.aspx?id=16414

They can protest at another time, a funeral is not the right place. Leave the family in peace.

But the question is, "Do they have a legal right to protest at these funerals?"



I'd have to say, yes, they do. Sure, it's sick, disgusting, heartless, and rude. But legal? Yep, it is.

I think if the protests continue, there probaly will soon be report about protestors being attacked. The funerals they are choosing to protest at are ones steeping in raw emotions.

They have a legal right to express their thoughts ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,I REALLY DISAGREE. Let's go back to the FAMILY................OOHHHHHHH - this is difficult for me. People work and they know the hazzards of their occupation.....their families know the hazzards ................everyone accepts it -----------but the NYC people can't.

Those guys have totally lost the plot. I was in Illinois in early December when there was a nasty protest at the local funeral of a soldier killed in Iraq. I couldn't believe it!!! His family coped with quiet dignity.

There's a time and a place for everything. A funeral is not the time or place to protest.

Strictly legally speaking (because you know I'd be shoulder to shoulder with Far), I'm not sure they weren't already breaking the law. Protesting is legal, sure, but aren't there city ordinances requiring that groups register & receive permission?



Funerals are private affairs, but they're held in public. I don't see how anyone can legally prevent them from standing anywhere near the funeral with protest signs & such - not legally anyway.



I'm glad they made the protests illegal. Somebody should assemble at that church and protest them.

They call themselves Christians. Glad I'm not one then.:-5

Peg wrote: They call themselves Christians. Glad I'm not one then.:-5
They probably call themselves patriots as well. :yh_frustr

Ok really sad. They list on their website upcoming funerals and protests planned. They are also planning to protest Coretta King's funeral.

Here's the link.............warning it's a sick site!

http://www.godhatesfags.com/main/index.html

:-4

Sheryl wrote: Ok really sad. They list on their website upcoming funerals and protests planned. They are also planning to protest Coretta King's funeral.



Here's the link.............warning it's a sick site!



http://www.godhatesfags.com/main/index.html


This site is truly sick. it just goes to show that there are extremists all over the place...I despair of the human race sometimes.

My heart goes out to the poor greaving folks that want to say goodbye to their loved ones in peace and with dignity.

On November 1st of last year, while out on patrol, one of the humvees in my husband's unit ran over an IED. The guys managed to pull 4 of the soldiers out but were unable to save the 5th man.

The survivors were all badly burned and sent to a military hospital in Texas. One of the soldiers died in December. Another died on the 1st of this month. He leaves behind a young wife and a 4 month old daughter that he got to meet once.

I am so upset to see that his funeral, scheduled for this weekend, is listed on the Phelps family website.

What state?

Michigan

Too far for me, but I know a patriotic biker in that area that might be interested.

It's so sad people are doing this. However we have had 2 funerals in our area in the last month. The protestors didn't show up, but people did show up in support.

Attached files

they can at ,,,, my fun run...... because I'm take the devils offer and being cramated so u are all welcome,,,, dust to dust and no pray in ok... no flowers

just bring a bottle of er favorite hooch ale wine water tea coffie,, no holy water

save that ,, for famin vic them.... not to be waste stead.... a love me wordslol daffy52

Watched on the news a very heart-warming story. Yet again, here in Michigan this time, a soldiers funeral was "visited" by about a dozen protesters. The thing that was different this time? About 150 Vietnam vets and BIKERS showed up to keep the protesters at bay.

These sick bastards that are protesting at the funerals were carrying signs that said things like "Faggot Vets" and other such niceties.

The bikers rallied round and drowned out the dozen or so protesters and allowed the family of the fallen soldier to have their ceremony in relative peace.



Way to go, brothers.



FTW!

BabyRider wrote: Watched on the news a very heart-warming story. Yet again, here in Michigan this time, a soldiers funeral was "visited" by about a dozen protesters. The thing that was different this time? About 150 Vietnam vets and BIKERS showed up to keep the protesters at bay.

These sick bastards that are protesting at the funerals were carrying signs that said things like "Faggot Vets" and other such niceties.

The bikers rallied round and drowned out the dozen or so protesters and allowed the family of the fallen soldier to have their ceremony in relative peace.



Way to go, brothers.



FTW!


That sounds like what happened to one of our local fallen soldiers' funeral. The protestors were saying the soldiers were being killed as punishment for gays in America. They were from some church in Kansas, I think. But the Vets caught wind of it & stood as a barricade against them.

LilacDragon wrote: On November 1st of last year, while out on patrol, one of the humvees in my husband's unit ran over an IED. The guys managed to pull 4 of the soldiers out but were unable to save the 5th man.



The survivors were all badly burned and sent to a military hospital in Texas. One of the soldiers died in December. Another died on the 1st of this month. He leaves behind a young wife and a 4 month old daughter that he got to meet once.



I am so upset to see that his funeral, scheduled for this weekend, is listed on the Phelps family website.




Phelps :rolleyes:

He shouldnt even be considered in the equation. He lives to cause harm. Pay him no heed.

I got this in an e-mail a few days ago. It is most excellent news for those who have family members in dangerous places.



Protests like those that marred two local military funerals last

week soon could become a thing of the past.

State and federal lawmakers are planning legislation that would put

strict limits on protests at military funerals ” effectively making

protesters barely visible, if at all.

Twice in one week protesters from the Westboro Baptist Church in

Kansas came to Genesee County. They stood on American flags while

holding signs condemning soldiers, the country and homosexuality at

the funerals for Pfc. Allan Morr, 21, of Byron, and Sgt. Joshua

Youmans, 26, of Flushing Township.

Now, U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Brighton, wants to keep the protesters

at a distance at national cemeteries and encourage states to put

limits everywhere else, too. He expects to introduce a bill on the

issue Wednesday or Thursday.

Both the state and federal proposals being talked about would keep

protesters at least 500 feet away ” the length of almost two

football fields ” and ban them entirely right before, during and

after a funeral.